Home Blog Insurance Claim Dispute: Challenge Denied Payments

Insurance Claim Dispute: Challenge Denied Payments

This page explains what an insurance claim dispute is, how to deal with it, and when to hire a lawyer from ContractsCounsel for help.

Jump to Section

Insurance claim disputes occur when insurers and policyholders argue over aspects of claims, such as coverage, payouts, and delays. These are a common occurrence, but they don’t have to land you in court or result in financial losses. There are ways to deal with them effectively.

Read the rest of this article to learn about common insurance claim disputes, how to handle them, how you can prevent them, and when you should contact a lawyer for assistance.

What are Common Insurance Claim Disputes?

Unpaid or delayed claims aren’t the only reasons for disputes between policyholders and insurers. Arguments and disagreements can arise over the following situations:

  • Insufficient settlements
  • Lack of coverage
  • Repeated documentation requests
  • Misunderstandings over policy terms and clauses
  • Not contacting policyholders over lapsed or cancelled policies
  • Coverage disagreements

How Can You Prevent Insurance Claim Disputes?

You can avoid the hassle of denied claims or other insurance disputes by ensuring you take some precautionary measures before filing and submitting a claim to your insurance company.

Read and Understand Your Policy

You should take the time to understand your insurance policy and know exactly what your coverage covers and what it doesn’t, so that you don’t submit a claim that’s denied.

Be Mindful of Lapses and Terminations

It’s important to know what will cause a lapse in your coverage or a cancellation of your policy. These should be outlined in your insurance documents.

Maintain Records

Keep and preserve records for all your insurance policies, such as information about claims, receipts for repairs, medical bills, and more. This will ensure you have all the documentation you need should you have to file or appeal a claim.

Request Written Information

If you’re dealing with denials, don’t give up. You should request information and explanations, and get them in writing so that you have proof.

Continue to pursue your insurer for answers. Being persistent is important to prevent disputes and resolve them before they escalate.

What Steps Should You Take to Deal with an Insurance Claim Dispute?

If you’re in the middle of a claim dispute with your insurance company, there are some important steps to take.

Review Your Policy

The first thing you should do is refer to your insurance policy. Find what it says about your coverage and the claims process. Sometimes the wording in such documents can be challenging to understand, but a policy review is important to ensure you can see your rights in print and understand what is owing to you.

If you need to get your policy legally reviewed, you should post a request for free on ContractsCounsel, an online legal network that connects clients with vetted lawyers for contract review and drafting. A lawyer on the platform will help you understand the policy and explain how you can pursue your claim dispute for the best outcome.

Contact the Insurer

Once you’ve reviewed your insurance policy, you should contact the insurance company to ask questions. If your claim is wrongfully denied, you should request information about the denial. Similarly, if you’re unsatisfied with a claim settlement, you should explain to them why it’s below your expectations or not in line with your policy coverage.

Keep Notes and Communications

You should keep notes about your interactions with the insurance company, down to emails, texts, and letters. When you have a record of all important documentation regarding your policy and dispute, you'll be able to reference it in future, if required.

Consult with a Lawyer

Hiring a lawyer from ContractsCounsel is worth doing as they will help you deal with the insurance claim dispute. These situations can be challenging or confusing, especially if you’ve never dealt with them before or your insurer isn’t responsive to your claim requests.

A lawyer can assist you in various ways throughout the claim dispute process, such as by:

  • Reviewing your insurance policy
  • Investigating your case to see if it’s valid
  • Exploring your options for resolving the dispute
  • Communicating with the insurer on your behalf
  • Negotiating with your insurer to receive a fair claim or settlement
  • Helping you file an appeal with your insurance company
  • Gathering all the necessary documents to strengthen your case
  • Pursuing legal options, such as lawsuits, if you’re dealing with an insurer who refuses to cooperate or who is operating in bad faith

What Legal Remedies are There For Insurance Claim Disputes?

Your lawyer can assist you with pursuing legal remedies for your specific insurance claim dispute. This can include the following.

Appealing the Denial

If you’re dealing with a denied claim, your insurance company will usually have an internal process you can use to appeal their decision. To appeal, you’ll have to submit a letter explaining reasons why you think their appeal is incorrect.

Your lawyer can help you with drafting the letter so that it’s legally sound and includes all the information required, as well as supporting documents.

Filing a Complaint with the State

Depending on the nature of your dispute, your lawyer might suggest reporting a complaint to your state’s insurance department, such as if your insurance company is refusing your appeal.

Consider Alternative Dispute-Resolution (ADR) Methods

It’s common for insurance disputes to be resolved through mediation or arbitration. This is because taking the dispute to court is a last resort, due to its high cost and lengthy duration.

  • Mediation involves hiring a neutral, third-party mediator to oversee communications between you and the insurer. It encourages you both to come up with a solution to the problem so that you can resolve the issue yourselves.
  • By comparison, arbitration is when you hire a neutral, third-party arbitrator to consider both parties’ cases and evidence, and then decide on a resolution to resolve the issues.

Your lawyer can advocate for you in both ADR processes. Check your insurance policy for any information about dispute-resolution processes that should be adopted if a disagreement comes up.

Do you need an insurance claim dispute lawyer?

If you’re dealing with an insurance dispute or the situation is escalating, you should contact a lawyer on ContractsCounsel. All lawyers are professional and vetted on the platform, providing you with expertise and skill to help you navigate insurance disputes with ease.


ContractsCounsel is not a law firm, and this post should not be considered and does not contain legal advice. To ensure the information and advice in this post are correct, sufficient, and appropriate for your situation, please consult a licensed attorney. Also, using or accessing ContractsCounsel's site does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and ContractsCounsel.


Need help with a dispute

Create a free project posting
Clients Rate Lawyers 4.9 Stars
based on 24,388 reviews

Meet some of our Lawyers

Jeff G. on ContractsCounsel
View Jeff
5.0 (19)
Member Since:
October 30, 2024

Jeff G.

Business Lawyer
Free Consultation
Raleigh, North Carolina
3 Yrs Experience
Licensed in IN, NC
Valparaiso University School of Law

Jeff has 25 years of commercial transactional experience within numerous industries, including finance/banking, telecommunications/utilities, insurance, and software. He is a recognized authority on contracts, software licensing and negotiation. Jeff earned his Juris Doctorate from Valparaiso University School of Law and his Masters in Business Administration from North Carolina State University and is licensed to practice law in North Carolina and Indiana.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
5.0

"Jeff was very knowledgeable about NC real estate and business law and provided me with the advice necessary for my specific case."

Benjamin G. on ContractsCounsel
View Benjamin
4.8 (17)
Member Since:
December 15, 2024

Benjamin G.

Senior Associate
Free Consultation
Erie, Michigan
16 Yrs Experience
Licensed in AL
Thomas Goode Jones School of Law, JD

16+ years of diverse legal experience within the military and substantial military leadership and supervisory experience. Portfolio captures experience in national security law (international law, maritime law, sensitive support, inter-agency agreements, rule of law, etc.), government contracts/procurement, administrative law, Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), fiscal law, labor law, civilian personnel law, harassment and hostile work environment, retaliation and whistleblower protection, medical disability, criminal law, and military law. Significant experience advising general/flag officers and senior executives; powerful oral and written communication skills. Post-military experience includes Landlord Tenant Law, Criminal Law, and Family Law.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
4.3

"Fast response update prenup to be more specific for my wants."

Edward B. on ContractsCounsel
View Edward
4.8 (50)
Member Since:
December 16, 2024

Edward B.

Managing Partner
Free Consultation
Orlando Florida
2 Yrs Experience
Licensed in FL
St. Thomas University College of Laww

When the pressure mounts and the outcome matters most, Edward L. Blair IV doesn’t just step up—he dominates. As a formidable Florida-based attorney, Mr. Blair commands every case with the unshakable focus of a warrior and the calculated precision of a master strategist. His expertise in drafting pleadings, motions, and contracts transforms legal writing into a sharp-edged instrument—an arsenal of language wielded with power and purpose. Edward L. Blair IV is not just an attorney—he’s a lionhearted force of advocacy. Every case is a mission, and every client is a cause worth fighting for. His strategic legal insight doesn’t just navigate complexity—it crushes confusion, eliminates doubt, and clears the path to victory. Respected by clients and relentless in pursuit of justice, he approaches each legal battle as a personal crusade. When you choose Blair Legal Solutions LLC, you gain more than representation—you gain a relentless ally. Your battle becomes his, and he won’t rest until the job is done.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
5.0

"Edward was excellent to work with. He explained everything clearly, delivered the trust package on schedule, and made the entire process smooth and stress‑free. The documents were well‑prepared and exactly what I needed. I truly appreciate his professionalism and care. Definitely a 5‑star experience."

Ricardo A. on ContractsCounsel
View Ricardo
4.8 (16)
Member Since:
December 24, 2024

Ricardo A.

Associate General Counsel
Free Consultation
San Antonio, Texas
24 Yrs Experience
Licensed in DC, TX
Interamerican Law School

Ricardo Aponte Parsi is a real estate and corporate counsel with a 22+-year track record of assessing risk, managing litigation, and building compliance systems to protect organizational interests. Trusted business partner and problem solver, dedicated to delivering exceptional results that advance business objectives through preventive counseling, strategic risk management, and shrewd advocacy. Collaborative team leader and project manager who builds relationships, leads change, and communicates effectively with private and public stakeholders. He obtained a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University (1994) with a major in International Relations and his law degree from the Interamerican University of Puerto Rico School of Law (2000). In May 2014, he completed a Master of Laws from Northwestern University School of Law and a Certificate in Business Administration from IE Business School in Madrid, Spain. In 2018, he completed a second LL.M. at Georgetown University Law School in Securities and Financial Regulation. In 2022, he completed a certification in Privacy Law from Seton Hall University School of Law. He was president of the Board of the Puerto Rico Education Council, the licensing agency for the Commonwealth, and is currently the Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the San Juan Community College. Since November of 2024, he has worked as an attorney-advisor for the United States Air Force Installations, Energy and Environmental Law Division (SAF/GCN) at Lackland Air Force Base, in San Antonio, Texas.SAF/GCN provides legal and policy advice to members of the Secretariat, the Air Staff, and the Space Staff on virtually all matters relating to the Department’s 180 installations, nearly 10 million acres of real estate, Base Realignment, and Closure; annual $7 billion installation and operational energy budgets; annual multibillion-dollar military construction program; $8.3 billion military privatized housing portfolio; programs for environmental planning, compliance, and restoration and natural and cultural resources management; and programs for safety and occupational health. The Division advises the Center of Excellence for Environment, Facilities, and Installations and the Energy, Environmental, and Installations Directorates within the Air Force Civil Engineer Center. Experienced with estate planning, wills, trusts, prenuptial agreements and powers of attorney.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
5.0

"Ricardo was excellent. His review was thorough and practical, with clear explanations and concrete wording we could use right away .I'd gladly work with him again."

Tsion L. on ContractsCounsel
View Tsion
4.7 (3)
Member Since:
December 19, 2024

Tsion L.

Fractinal General Counsel
Free Consultation
Los Angeles, California
14 Yrs Experience
Licensed in CA
Stanford Law School

Seasoned Fractional COO and Legal Counsel with a proven track record of driving operational excellence and legal compliance in high-growth companies. Skilled in developing and executing strategic plans, optimizing business processes, and managing complex legal matters. Demonstrated ability to draft commercial, partnership, and sponsorship agreements, file trademark applications and manage IP portfolios, support corporate filings and board governance. Industries served: small and medium sized small business, cannabis, hemp, consumer goods, e-commerce, SAAs and health and wellness.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
5.0

"Great experience, very responsive and professionally handled our needs."

Dan P. on ContractsCounsel
View Dan
4.6 (5)
Member Since:
December 10, 2024

Dan P.

Founder
Free Consultation
New Jersey
29 Yrs Experience
Licensed in NJ
Delaware Law School at Widener University

Dan C. Pelletier is a New Jersey real estate attorney with 29 years of legal experience and the founder of Ocean Avenue Land & Legacy, an Asbury Park based real estate and estate planning practice. Dan’s practice focuses on commercial leasing, real estate transactions, property transfers and estate planning. He has substantial experience reviewing, drafting and negotiating commercial leases and other real estate agreements, with commercial leasing experience extending back through his work with Riley Riper Hollin & Colagreco and subsequent real estate and investment work. Throughout his career, Dan has worked on real estate from several perspectives—as outside counsel, transactional attorney and asset manager. That background allows him to approach a lease or transaction not simply as a document to be marked up, but as a business arrangement requiring a practical assessment of risk, economics and the parties’ respective obligations. For commercial lease clients, Dan focuses on identifying the provisions that materially matter: rent and additional rent obligations, operating expenses and CAM charges, repair and maintenance responsibilities, insurance and indemnification, permitted use, assignment and subletting, options, guarantees, default remedies, casualty, condemnation and termination rights. His broader real estate practice includes purchase and sale agreements, deeds and property transfers, ownership and entity issues, and related contract matters. Dan also assists New Jersey clients with straightforward estate and legacy planning, including wills, powers of attorney, healthcare directives, revocable trusts and planning involving real property. Dan founded Ocean Avenue Land & Legacy to provide experienced legal counsel in a practical, accessible manner. His approach is direct: understand the client’s objective, identify the meaningful risks, explain them clearly and develop a workable path forward.

Recent  ContractsCounsel Client  Review:
5.0

"Very knowledgeable and helpful. We would work with him again ."

Patrick W. on ContractsCounsel
View Patrick
Member Since:
October 31, 2024

Patrick W.

Lawyer
Free Consultation
Novato, CA, USA
12 Yrs Experience
Licensed in CA
Santa Clara SOL

Patrick is a seasoned attorney with over 11 years of experience in corporate law, commercial contracts, and regulatory compliance, with a specialization in emerging technologies such as AI and Web 3.0. Patrick works with commercial contract negotiations for technology startups, managing multi-million-dollar agreements, and offering comprehensive corporate governance services, including stock plan administration, cap table management, and day to day advising. One of Patrick’s career highlights includes his tenure at SharesPost Inc., a pioneering fintech startup, where he served as Senior Legal Counsel and later Interim General Counsel. In this role, Patrick led product legal risk management, negotiated SaaS and data processing agreements, and ensured compliance with SEC, FINRA, and DBO regulations. He played a pivotal role in the company's growth working closely with operations and sales, until such time teh company was acquired. In addition to his work at SharesPost, Patrick’s experience includes serving as Policy Counsel at Bird Global and General Counsel and Chief Compliance Officer for Planned Parenthood Northern California, where he oversaw a $60M revenue organization, directed legal strategy for EHR migration, and ensured compliance with state and federal privacy laws.

John B. on ContractsCounsel
View John
Member Since:
November 6, 2024

John B.

Attorney
Free Consultation
Shaker Heights, OH, USA
8 Yrs Experience
Licensed in OH
Temple University Beasley School of Law

J. D. Bridges has worked both in-house and in firms and has seen countless commercial agreements and technology deals from every angle. J. D.’s worked as in-house counsel for high-growth, VC-backed startups, IT solutions providers and cybersecurity companies and also at an AmLaw Top 50 global firm, representing clients in a variety of industries and purchasers and creators of technology across the globe. He’s negotiated commercial contracts with some of the world’s largest financial services and pharmaceutical companies, as well as assisting startups from incorporation to exit. He’s also helped Fortune 100 companies protect themselves and their data when procuring technology from startups and legacy technology providers alike. ‍ J. D. brings a practical and growth-focused mindset to legal advice and excels in working with front-line sales organizations and sales leadership as well as internal counsel, business owners and procurement professionals. Whether a pre-seed AI startup, established manufacturer or a global IT procurement effort, J. D. can support you while concurrently growing and protecting your business.

Alyssa C. on ContractsCounsel
View Alyssa
Member Since:
November 13, 2024

Alyssa C.

Attorney
Free Consultation
Chicago, IL
11 Yrs Experience
Licensed in IL, MO
George Mason University School of Law

Illinois-licensed attorney with 9 years of experience in public interest work utilizing advanced skills in contract & project management, compliance, investigation, risk management, & training. Proven record developing and managing partnerships to deliver exceptional results in government agencies, non-profits, law firms, and broad community networks leading to multi-million dollar recoveries, risk management, and execution of large-scale program initiatives. Skills include: 1. Project & Contract Management: 9 years in project & contract management tracking project and contract goals, stages, budgets, and deliverables to lead and support program and department initiatives. 2. Compliance, Investigation, & Risk Management: 9 years in law, policy, & programs conducting investigation, research, writing, analysis, and education in administrative agency and court matters relating to: compliance, financial regulation, contracts, employment, workforce development, healthcare, retirement assets, mental health, disability, taxes, immigration, civil rights, grants, benefits, social services, & criminal defense. 3. Training/Teaching: 4 years training co-workers & community partners; 3 years teaching in U.S. & Ecuador (7 total). 4. Technology: Microsoft Office (including Excel), Contract Express, DocuSign, SharePoint, Westlaw, Lexis Nexis, Concordance, GoldFynch, Clio, Smokeball, Qualtrics, Google Forms, Slack, Zoom, Teams, Webex, & Adobe. 5. Spanish: Advanced Spanish skills from 1 year of teaching, studying, & travel in Ecuador, Peru, & Mexico.

Feras M. on ContractsCounsel
View Feras
Member Since:
December 21, 2024

Feras M.

Managing Partner
Free Consultation
Houston, Texas
23 Yrs Experience
Licensed in TX
University of Texas School of Law

Feras Mousilli is a globally recognized leader in intellectual property, entrepreneurship, and corporate strategy. As the founder and managing partner of Lloyd & Mousilli, he has driven scalable growth strategies for Fortune 500 companies as well as innovative startups in emerging markets.

Benjamin E. on ContractsCounsel
View Benjamin
Member Since:
December 24, 2024

Benjamin E.

State Agency Director; CEO; Professor
Free Consultation
Boise, Idaho
10 Yrs Experience
Licensed in ID
University of Idaho College of Law

Dr. Ben Earwicker, J.D., Ph.D., is the director and administrator of the Idaho Human Rights Commission, the state-wide administrative law agency within the Idaho Department of Labor that enforces anti-discrimination law in Idaho. Prior to his work in administrative employment and civil rights law, he served as a faculty member and administrator at universities in the U.S. and New Zealand for 13 years and managed dual-enrollment modern language courses throughout Washington, Oregon, and Idaho. Ben is the CEO of VirNet Virtual Mediation, an online mediation platform with clients throughout the United States and abroad. He holds a Juris Doctorate from the University of Idaho College of Law, a Ph.D. in Spanish and Latin American Studies and a Master’s of International Studies from the University of Otago in New Zealand, and Bachelor of Arts Degrees in Psychology, Social Work, Spanish, and International Studies from Northwest Nazarene University.

Find the best lawyer for your project

Browse Lawyers Now

Quick, user friendly and one of the better ways I've come across to get ahold of lawyers willing to take new clients.

View Trustpilot Review

Need help with a dispute

Create a free project posting
Clients Rate Lawyers 4.9 Stars
based on 24,388 reviews
CONTRACT LAWYERS BY TOP CITIES
See All Insurance Lawyers
INSURANCE CLAIM DISPUTE LAWYERS BY CITY
See All Insurance Claim Dispute Lawyers

Contracts Counsel was incredibly helpful and easy to use. I submitted a project for a lawyer's help within a day I had received over 6 proposals from qualified lawyers. I submitted a bid that works best for my business and we went forward with the project.

View Trustpilot Review

I never knew how difficult it was to obtain representation or a lawyer, and ContractsCounsel was EXACTLY the type of service I was hoping for when I was in a pinch. Working with their service was efficient, effective and made me feel in control. Thank you so much and should I ever need attorney services down the road, I'll certainly be a repeat customer.

View Trustpilot Review

I got 5 bids within 24h of posting my project. I choose the person who provided the most detailed and relevant intro letter, highlighting their experience relevant to my project. I am very satisfied with the outcome and quality of the two agreements that were produced, they actually far exceed my expectations.

View Trustpilot Review

Need help with a dispute

Create a free project posting
Clients Rate Lawyers 4.9 Stars
based on 24,388 reviews

Want to speak to someone?

Get in touch below and we will schedule a time to connect!

Request a call

Find lawyers and attorneys by city