What is a Contract Dispute?
A contract dispute happens when one or more parties disagree on the terms, definitions, and conditions contained within it. In such a case, the contract may be contested in court.
A contract dispute arises between parties in a confidentiality agreement or nondisclosure agreement when information or intellectual property has been shared against the contract’s obligations.
Although contracts are often negotiated, people do not always see eye-to-eye. When there is a breach of contract, or one or both parties disagree on the terms or definitions contained in the contract, a contract dispute can arise.
Here is an article about the legal definition of a contract dispute.
Who Can Dispute a Contract?
Any involved party can dispute a contract, but it generally occurs when one party accuses another of a breach of contract.
Under this breach, one party asserts that one or more parties have not fulfilled their agreement's conditions or have violated previously agreed-upon terms.
All parties can sue one another for damages as the result of a contract breach. In case of a confidentiality and non-compete agreement breach, a party may sue another for using intellectual property or stealing ideas for personal gain.
It is not uncommon for one party to dispute a contract and be countered by the accused party. For example, they may claim that there were limitations to the terms not covered under the initial contract, which renders their actions legal and just.
Ultimately, if mediation cannot occur amicably through an attorney, the contract dispute may go to court.
Here is an article about what constitutes a legal contract.
How Do You Dispute a Contract?
If you want to dispute a signed contract, you can send a letter of termination to the contract issuer.
In most business contracts, a contract termination agreement outlines the requirements for cancellation. This may include a monetary fee or other requirements, such as removing all references to a business to avoid any future affiliation.
If you deliberately breach a contract, you can face penalties under the contract’s terms and conditions. These vary by contract, and it is not advisable to deliberately breach a signed agreement without first consulting with an attorney.
Working with an attorney who knows contract law well can prevent you from making any big mistakes that result in major financial losses or even legal penalties.
If you are disputing a non-competition agreement, you will need to demonstrate there is no need to enforce such agreement or prove there has been a breach of contract. You may also argue that the terms of a contract were not set for a fair amount of time.
Remember that every contract lays out limitations for its parties to adhere to; if you feel that these terms somehow negatively affect your business’s performance, you may use that defense to justify disputing the contract.
Here is an article that can help you find loopholes in a non-compete agreement.
Image via Pexels by Karolina Grabowska
Types of Contract Disputes
The most common contract disputes arise from a breach of contract. There are two types of contract breaches to know.
- Material breach: This is a complete breach, meaning the rest of the contract is null and void. Also known as a total breach, a material breach of contract means that the affected parties are no longer required to fulfill their obligations and may decide to sue the breaching party or parties for damages.
- Minor breach: A minor breach of contract does not completely nullify the terms and conditions of the agreement. For example, in a confidential information agreement, a minor breach may result in some damages that a party can sue for compensation. Still, it does not mean the breaching party must no longer uphold their agreed-upon obligations.
It is easy to differentiate between material and minor breach by considering the goals and consequences of the actions. For example, suppose a person or company’s actions alter the goals of an agreement entirely. Then, a material breach is likely to blame.
If a goal is achieved, but it is not done so in an agreed-upon fashion or under false pretenses, then a minor breach has occurred.
There are several other types of common contract disputes you may encounter.
1. Non-disclosure Agreement Dispute
A non-disclosure agreement (NDA), also known as a confidential disclosure agreement (CDA), protects an individual or business’s sensitive information from public knowledge or personal use.
For example, a company partnering with a consultant may have them sign a CDA or NDA to prevent sharing their patented technology or methodologies with others.
A contract dispute can then arise if the contract issuer accuses the signee of sharing, leaking, or stealing information.
2. Consumer Contract Dispute
When consumers purchase a product with a warranty, they expect to be sold an item free of any hazards or defects.
Suppose a company sells a product with a warranty that violates the said warranty. The consumer may sue the company for a breach of contract.
Although it requires no signature, a product warranty is a contract between the seller/manufacturer and the consumer. If a product harms a consumer or does not work according to its promised and advertised standards, consumers may sue for damages.
3. Partnership Dispute
Modern companies rely heavily on partnerships with other businesses. When a company feels its partner has not fulfilled its requirements or otherwise breached a partnership agreement, it may sue for damages.
However, a partnership must have clear objectives, expectations, and requirements in its terms and conditions. Otherwise, it can be difficult for a company to prove that a legal breach has occurred.
This is why measurable objectives are always beneficial in company agreements. It is another reason monetary compensation or data-driven transactions are so common; it is easier for all parties to be held accountable when quantitative figures are used as part of their agreement.
4. Sale of Goods Dispute
Sales of goods contracts between suppliers and merchants are prone to disputes due to their open-ended nature and often vague terms.
In a sales of goods contract, the merchant trusts that the supplier will provide goods to their customers. As a result, disputes over failure to deliver products as advertised or even ship them are highly common between wholesale merchants and their suppliers.
If a product does not arrive in a timely manner, is never shipped, or is significantly not as described (SNAD). A merchant may sue the supplier for a breach of contract.
Here is an article to learn more about civil wrongs and what might qualify as a breach of your contract.
What Causes a Contract Dispute?
Any suspected or potential breach of contract can lead to a dispute. All it takes is one party to believe another has broken the agreement to cause a dispute.
No legal guidelines determine what someone can or cannot take a dispute over. However, to prove their case, the accusing party will need to bring forth a sound argument and any evidence that the accused has violated their agreement.
3 Ways to Resolve a Contract Dispute
There are three ways that parties may go about resolving a dispute. These are:
- Renegotiating terms with a mediator, i.e., an attorney, and revising the contract.
- Mutually agreeing to terminate the contract.
- Suing for damages and compensation in court.
Suppose parties are willing to negotiate, even through their own attorneys. In that case, you may be able to resolve contract disputes without needing to go to court.
How Do You Avoid a Contract Dispute?
The easiest way to avoid a contract dispute is to use a contract lawyer to draw up all agreements before signing.
Sound legal contracts set clear expectations, requirements, and terms for all parties.
Negotiating contracts before signing is also a good way to prevent disputes. If all parties feel that they are receiving a fair and equitable deal, they are less likely to breach the contract later.
Unfortunately, disputes are not always preventable. However, open communication, willingness to negotiate and compromise, and clear termination clauses in all agreements can prevent lengthy disputes.
Post a project in ContractsCounsel’s marketplace to receive flat fee bids from lawyers for your project. All lawyers have been vetted by our team and peer-reviewed by our customers for you to explore before hiring.
Meet some of our Contract Dispute Lawyers
April 21, 2022
Orly Boger has worked in the high tech industry and in a leading law firm before launching her law firm. Orly focuses on startup companies and technology transactions. She structures and negotiates software and technology license agreements, strategic partnerships, cloud-based/SaaS agreements, internet related transactions, OEM agreements, supply, distribution, telecommunications. In addition, Orly has experience in serving as an in-house legal counsel for start up companies at various phases of their development, providing strategic legal advise to entrepreneurs and emerging companies with a comprehensive understanding of the business and legal issues. She has been helping companies develop a legal strategy for all aspects of their operations, from commercial transactions and partnerships, scalable SaaS or services agreements, privacy policies, employment related policies, open source licensing and much more.
April 16, 2022
Corporate attorney with 13+ years of in-house counsel, people leadership and client management experience. Provides legal expertise and a business-oriented approach to problem solving and building lines of business. Consistently works under pressure, prioritizing and managing workload and simultaneous tasks to meet deadlines in a changing, fast-paced environment.
May 4, 2022
As a corporate lawyer, I have dealt with international transactions, complex litigation and arbitration, regulatory compliance, and multijurisdictional tax planning. In March 2021, I started my firm and shifted my professional focus to working with start-ups, small businesses, entrepreneurs, and families. I help my clients structure and run their businesses and take care of their assets, including intellectual property issues and estate planning for their families. I try to bring big law quality and small firm personal attention to every client.
May 27, 2022
I am a solo-practitioner with a practice mostly consisting of serving as a fractional general counsel to growth stage companies. With a practical business background, I aim to bring real-world, economically driven solutions to my client's legal problems and pride myself on efficient yet effective work.
March 28, 2022
Freelance attorney helping others beat overflow work by assisting with legal research, legal drafting, discovery, litigation support and client relations.
May 16, 2022
Jerry provides legal advice to business owners regarding contracts, business law, labor & employment, wills and estates, and real estate.
April 20, 2022
Seasoned professional with experience in wide variety of contract negotiation and review.
May 2, 2022
I primarily work with small businesses and the self-employed. I help my clients build sustainable businesses, navigate risk, and resolve conflicts. Most of my cases involve contract review, drafting, negotiation, and disputes; I also work on business entity formation, employment and independent contractor issues, copyright licenses, trademark registration, and more.
May 4, 2022
Attorney that has worked in both litigation and transactional fields. Motivated and personable professional. Speaks fluent Spanish and very basic Portuguese.
May 5, 2022
Seven years experience reviewing and drafting corporate and transactional documents, including NDAs, LLC operating agreements, MSAs, employment agreements, etc.
May 6, 2022
I am licensed in New York and New Jersey. I graduated with my J.D. from Touro University Law Center, Summa Cum Laude, in 2021. In 2018, I graduated from SUNY Farmingdale with a B.S. in Sport Management and a minor in Business Management. I have experience in real estate law and insurance defense, including employment law. Please note, I do not carry malpractice insurance.