Home Q&A Forum Can a multi-member LLC operating agreement be amended without the consent of all members?

Small Business

Multi-Member LLC Operating Agreement

New York

Asked on Dec 6, 2024

Can a multi-member LLC operating agreement be amended without the consent of all members?

I am a member of a multi-member LLC and we currently have an operating agreement in place that was agreed upon when the company was formed. However, there have been changes in the business and we feel that certain provisions in the operating agreement need to be amended to better reflect our current needs and goals. Some members are hesitant to make these changes and we are unsure if the operating agreement can be amended without the consent of all members or if unanimous consent is required. We are seeking clarification on the process of amending the operating agreement and the level of consensus needed among the members.

Answers from 1 Lawyer

Answer

Small Business

New York

Answered 508 days ago

Damien B.

ContractsCounsel verified

Business Lawyer
Licensed in New York
4.9 (13)
Member Since:
October 3, 2023

Hello! My name is Damien Bosco, Esq. My law office is located in Long Island City across from Manhattan. If the operating agreement is silent on amendments, the default rule under New York's Limited Liability Company Law (LLCL) would apply. According to Section 402 with exceptions in Section 417 of the LLC Law, the operating agreement can generally be amended by a majority vote of the members, unless the agreement specifically requires unanimous consent for amendments. However, certain provisions require the consent of a member adversely affected by the amendment.: A) the obligations of any member to make contributions, (B) the allocation for tax purposes of any items of income, gain, loss, deduction, or credit, (C) the manner of computing the distributions of any member or (D) the compromise of an obligation of a member to contribute is contained in the articles of organization. If there are to be amendments without unanimous consent, it is better to have an attorney supervise the amendment process on behave of the LLC to make sure the amendment process is following NY law.

Use of the ContractsCounsel Q&A Forum does not create an attorney-client relationship between User and any Lawyer User. The Forum is not a substitute for legal advice from a lawyer but is intended to be educational and to help the user determine if legal services are necessary. The Forum, Content, and communications on the Forum do not constitute legal advice.
Meet some lawyers on our platform

Kristen R.

55 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Chaz G.

1 project on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Edward B.

73 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Dolan W.

871 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

People Also Asked

Business

Multi-Member LLC Operating Agreement

New York

Asked on Jun 11, 2024

Can a multi-member LLC operating agreement be amended without the unanimous consent of all members?

I am a member of a multi-member LLC and we currently have an operating agreement in place that was agreed upon by all members at the time of formation. However, there have been changes in the business and we need to make some amendments to the operating agreement to reflect these changes. One of the members is now refusing to give their consent to the proposed amendments, claiming that unanimous consent is required. I would like to know if it is possible to amend the operating agreement without the unanimous consent of all members, and if so, what steps need to be taken to do so legally.

4.9 (13)

Damien B.

Answered Jun 15, 2024

Hello! This is Attorney Damien Bosco. My law office is in Forest Hills, Queens County, New York City. My practice covers the New York City metropolitan area and Long Island. In some situations, I also handle matters throughout New York State. Under New York law, the requirements for amending an LLC's operating agreement are generally governed by the terms specified in the operating agreement. The operating agreement typically outlines how amendments can be made. This could require: - Unanimous Consent: All members must agree to any changes. - Majority or Supermajority Vote: A specified percentage (e.g., a majority or supermajority) of members' votes is sufficient to approve amendments. - Specific Procedures: Specific procedures or conditions under which amendments can be proposed and approved. If the operating agreement is silent on the amendment process, New York law generally defaults to requiring a majority vote for decisions unless otherwise stated. However, case law research may be necessary to confirm that a majority vote suffices for amending an operating agreement when the agreement is silent on the subject, especially if it adversely affects a minority member. In other words, although a majority vote to amend may be permissible, minority members do have some rights. A squeeze-out, also known as a freeze-out, is when a majority member of a limited liability company (LLC) takes actions to reduce or eliminate a minority member's involvement in the business It may be best for you to have a legal consultation with an attorney about this.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Small Business

Shareholders Agreement

Florida

Asked on Jun 15, 2023

Shareholders agreement and dividend policies?

I am a shareholder in a small business and am looking to understand the implications of a shareholders agreement and dividend policies on my ownership rights. I am considering entering into a shareholders agreement but want to ensure that I understand how dividends will be paid out and what rights I will have to receive my share of profits.

View Daniel D.
5.0 (3)

Daniel D.

Answered Jul 18, 2023

The shareholder agreement should specify your ownership rights and the policy on dividends. Or, the LLC Operating Agreement or Corporate By Laws could state when, to who and how frequent dividends are given out. Without seeing the shareholder agreement it is difficult to say what your rights will be and how the dividends will be paid out as each small business is unique.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Small Business

Waiver And Release Agreement

Texas

Asked on Feb 11, 2022

I am a tennis coach as a side hustle in Austin, TX. Considering getting basic general liability coverage with an insurance company. If I do I would need to have my students sign a waiver. Is this something you can help with and is it absolutely necessary to have the document notarized or not?

I am a tennis coach as a side hustle in Austin, TX. Considering getting basic general liability coverage with an insurance company. If I do I would need to have my students sign a waiver. Is this something you can help with and is it absolutely necessary to have the document notarized or not?

4.8 (12)

Kelvin R.

Answered Mar 18, 2022

A waiver and release of liability is a good idea. We can draft a provision for you to include in your existing agreement or as a stand alone waiver agreement. It is not necessary that waiver be notarized.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Small Business

LLC

Texas

Asked on Oct 25, 2023

Why hire a lawyer for LLC formation?

I am a small business owner looking to form a Limited Liability Company (LLC). I am aware of the various steps involved in forming an LLC, such as filing paperwork with the state, but I am unsure of the legal ramifications and potential risks associated with this type of business structure. I am seeking advice from a lawyer to understand the legal implications of forming an LLC and to ensure that I am taking the necessary steps to protect my business and my personal assets.

View Michael C.
5.0 (16)

Michael C.

Answered Oct 31, 2023

Here are some of the key reasons why it can be beneficial to hire a lawyer when forming an LLC: - Expertise navigating legal requirements - Forming an LLC involves meeting specific legal and regulatory requirements under state law. A business lawyer can help ensure you take all the necessary steps to properly create and register your LLC so that it obtains legal recognition and protections. - Assistance with operating agreement - Lawyers can draft a customized operating agreement that outlines the ownership structure, member responsibilities, profit/loss distributions, voting rights, and other rules governing your LLC. This agreement is important for establishing how your LLC will operate. - Advice on tax implications - LLCs can choose different tax treatments (like being taxed as a sole proprietorship, partnership, S-corp or C-corp). A lawyer can help you understand the tax implications of these options. - Ongoing legal advice - After forming the LLC, you may need guidance on legal issues like liability protection, employing workers, licensing, contracts, intellectual property, etc. A lawyer can provide trusted counsel. - Compliance with regulations - Lawyers stay up-to-date on all current LLC regulations and can help ensure your LLC remains compliant as laws evolve. Non-compliance can result in penalties or loss of LLC status. The bottom line is that an experienced business lawyer can help you avoid potential mistakes when forming an LLC and provide ongoing guidance to maintain the legal protections an LLC provides. Their expertise makes the lawyer fees worthwhile for many small business owners.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Small Business

LLC

Texas

Asked on Jan 1, 2025

What is the purpose of a Certificate of Organization?

I am in the process of starting a new business and I have been advised to file a Certificate of Organization. I understand that this document is required for limited liability companies (LLCs) and serves as proof of the company's existence. However, I would like to know more about the specific purpose of a Certificate of Organization, what information it typically includes, and any potential legal implications or consequences of not filing this document.

Phillip Z.

Answered Jan 25, 2025

A Certificate of Organization as your LLC's birth certificate in Texas. When you file Form 205, you're officially creating your business and getting all the legal protections that come with it. You'll need to include some basic info: - your company name (with "LLC" in it), - who'll receive any legal papers (that's your registered agent), - where you're located, and - how the company will be managed. You must send the $300 filing fee to the Texas Secretary of State with Form 205. Just remember—without this certificate, your business isn't officially recognized. That means you could be personally liable for any business debts or legal issues, and you'll have trouble with basic things like opening a bank account.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Find lawyers and attorneys by city