Copyright fair use is a principle set up on the belief that the public can freely use portions of copyrighted materials for commentary and other research work. Fair use is a legal notion that encourages freedom of expression by allowing the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances. Let’s learn more about several aspects of copyright fair use.
Elements of Copyright Fair Use
Although the judiciary developed the notion of fair use, it is now included in the Copyright Act. The Act requires four considerations to be examined when determining whether certain conduct is "fair use." These elements are as follows:
- Use, Purpose, and Characteristics: The copying party used the quotations in a for-profit publication (and so the use was for commercial advantage) while analyzing the first element. In general, this means that the first criterion leans heavily in favor of finding no fair usage. On the other hand, the fact that the goal of the use was to critique or criticize the work is a factor that favors a conclusion of fair use.
- Nature of the Copyrighted Work: A book is one of the best examples of a work that should be protected by copyright law when analyzing the second component in an example. As a result, the second factor weighs heavily in favor of a finding of no fair use. This component assesses how closely the work relates to the aim of copyright, which is to encourage creative expression.
- Quantity and Substantiality Taken: The review only included brief passages from the text for the third component. This often signifies that the third criterion is weighed in favor of a fair usage determination. This component, however, considers both the "quality" and the "quantity" of the piece consumed. These few passages could be the most crucial elements of the narrative. If this is the case, the third criterion could lead to a finding of no fair use. Courts consider both the quantity and quality of copyrighted material in this consideration.
- Impact on the Potential Market for Protected Work: Finally, the fourth component should be examined in our scenario. The courts have stated that this is the most crucial aspect of the fair use analysis. In this scenario, a bad review would influence the prospective market for the value of the copyrighted work. However, courts have held that this factor looks only at the section used to analyze the influence on the potential market and not at any unfavorable comments contained in a review.
Protection Granted under Copyright Fair Use
The right to restrict the use of one's creative work is guaranteed under Title 17 of the United States Code, which deals with copyright law:
Rights of Copyright Owners
- Distribution: Copyright owners have the exclusive right to distribute their creative works to the public. This includes producing duplicates of the work and putting them out for purchase, rental, or loan.
- Reproduction: Creative work owners who own the copyright to their creations can make copies of those works in print, digital, or audio formats.
- Display: Owners of copyrights are entitled to publicly exhibit their creative works, such as by putting on exhibitions or galleries to display visual art, such as paintings, photos, or sculptures.
- Derivative Works: Copyright holders can produce works based on their original works. Derivative works are new creations that expand or adapt the original work, such as adaptations, sequels, prequels, or other new works.
- Performance: Public performance of works is permitted for owners of copyrights. This includes live audiences' intended viewing or participation in public performances of music, plays, dance choreography, or any other type of creative work.
Works Protected under Copyright Law
- Literature: This encompasses written works such as novels, poems, short stories, essays, and articles.
- Music: Copyright protects musical compositions, including lyrics, melodies, and harmonies.
- Visual Creations: Copyright extends to films, videos, television shows, documentaries, and other visual creations.
- Sound Recordings: Copyright protects audio recordings such as music albums, spoken-word recordings, podcasts, and audio novels.
- Pantomimes and Choreography: Copyright protects choreographed dances and mime performances.
- Pictorials, Graphics, and Sculptures: Visual arts, such as paintings, drawings, illustrations, photographs, sculptures, and other artistic creations, are protected by copyright.
- Architectural Designs: Architectural designs, including construction plans and blueprints, are eligible for copyright protection.
Aspects Not Protected by Copyright Law
- Ideas: Abstract ideas, concepts, or thoughts are not protected by copyright. It simply protects the manifestation or expression of those beliefs.
- Facts: Copyright does not protect factual data or information. However, a creative presentation or synthesis of facts may be protected by copyright.
- Names and Titles: Names, titles, and short phrases are not protected by copyright. Other intellectual property rights, such as trademarks, may protect them.
- Slogans: Slogans, like names and titles, are not usually protected by copyright but may be eligible for trademark protection.
- Speeches: Speeches that are not written down or recorded in tangible media are not covered by copyright. On the other hand, a written or recorded version of a speech can be protected.
While copyright does not protect facts or ideas, it does protect the author's language or expression. Titles and slogans connected with a particular good or service are eligible for trademark protection.
1 project on CC
Practice of Copyright Fair Use
The following points represent the practice of copyright fair use in the United States:
- The Burden of Proof and Affirmative Defense: According to the United States Supreme Court, fair use is an affirmative defense, which means that in copyright infringement proceedings, the defendant carries the burden of establishing that the use was fair and not an infringement. Unless the plaintiff proves a prima facie charge of copyright infringement, the defender is not required to raise the fair use defense.
- Anti-SLAPP Legislation and Potential Strategic Lawsuits: Some copyright holders may allege infringement even though the fair use defense will likely win. This method discourages consumers from using protected information by threatening them with costly legal battles. This strategy, known as strategic litigation against public participation (SLAPP), may infringe on the defendant's right to free expression.
- Licensing and Practical Considerations: While fair use affords certain rights and defenses, many content creators and publishers choose to get licenses from copyright holders, even where a fair use defense is likely to succeed. This decision is frequently motivated by avoiding legal conflicts and the accompanying costs.
- Non-Binding Disclaimers and Binding Contracts: Non-binding disclaimers or notifications cannot invalidate a work's fair use right. The author's interests are prioritized over fair use rights. Binding arrangements, like contracts or license agreements, may supersede fair use rights. The parties may agree upon the terms.
- Case-by-Case Evaluation: Considering all circumstances, fair use is determined on a case-by-case basis. When performed by different means or for a different purpose, the same act might either earn or lose fair use status. Each case is assessed by considering and balancing all four fair usage elements.
Key Terms for Copyright Fair Use
- Transformative Use: Using copyrighted content in a fresh, innovative way that adds something new and modifies the intent, meaning, or expression of the original work.
- Parody and Satire: The transformation of copyrighted information into humor, mockery, or social commentary through the imitation or mockery of the source material.
- Quoting: Using a specific quotation or passage from a copyrighted work to support or illustrate a point.
- Excerpting: Choosing and utilizing relevant chunks or sections of a copyrighted work rather than the complete source.
- Summarizing: Providing a summary or overview of a copyrighted work's key ideas or points.
Final Thoughts on Copyright Fair Use
Fair use is an important feature of copyright law that permits limited use of copyrighted content without authorization. Its transformative, educational, and creative applications include criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, research, parody, and more. Fair use considers variables such as the user's purpose, nature, volume, and market impact. It achieves a compromise between defending the rights of creators and encouraging innovation, free expression, and public access to information.
If you want free pricing proposals from vetted lawyers that are 60% less than typical law firms, click here to get started. By comparing multiple proposals for free, you can save the time and stress of finding a quality lawyer for your business needs.
