ContractsCounsel has assisted 164 clients with safe notes and maintains a network of 102 business lawyers available daily. These lawyers collectively have 32 reviews to help you choose the best lawyer for your needs.
A SAFE note is a security that allows one to invest in equity in a firm, while a convertible note is a loan instrument changed into equity. This article will, therefore, look at the comparative differences between SAFE notes and convertible notes to give more insight into these advantages and considerations for investors. Allowing you to make informed choices in the complex startup financing landscape, regardless of whether you are an investor or startup founder, it is vital to comprehend these variations.
Overview of a SAFE Note
SAFE ( Simple agreement for future equity ) note is a financial instrument widely used in startup financing. It was designed specifically for early-stage start-ups, providing them with an efficient and flexible way of raising capital while enabling investors to participate in their future success.
Dissimilar to conventional equity financings, where investors instantly become owners of shares of the company’s stock, under SAFE notes terms, there isn’t any immediate issuance of stock. The convertible security becomes equity later, at some specified event, such as a subsequent funding round or acquisition.
Overview of a Convertible Note
A note that can be converted into shares is another common type of debt instrument found in startups. That means they take money from venture capitalists like loans with conditions where those may become equities on certain other occasions – typical conversions happening during future rounds of funding temporarily called rounds or when companies are bought out.
On receipt of funds through a convertible note, the investor receives a promissory note from the startup representing the loan. Unlike traditional debt instruments, which carry fixed repayment terms and interest rates, convertible notes have conversion features that allow them to convert into equity according to predetermined terms set forth by the issuer.
9 projects on CC
CC verified
Difference Between SAFE Notes & Convertible Notes
Both SAFE as well as convertibles are popular investment instruments used in start-up financing but have several points where they differ significantly. Here are some key distinctions between those two forms:
- Equity Conversion: There are different ways by which SAFE notes and convertible notes can be changed into equity. Mostly, SAFE notes convert into equities in the next round of funding or during an acquisition based on a certain formula that was pre-decided. Conversely, convertible notes have a predefined conversion ratio/rate that enables them to change into equities after some time at a specific conversion event.
- Valuation: This means that when investing in SAFE notes, one does not know what the valuation is at the time they commit funds because valuations are done during subsequent financing rounds. However, convertible notes often ascribe a specific value to their securities for cap purposes, or the price may be set before the issuance of such paper.
- Investor Protection: While both SAFE notes and convertible notes may contain protections for investors, these could vary depending on the nature of those. In most cases with SAFE notes, there will be a valuation cap together with discount rates, which would make sure that investors enjoy beneficially advantageous conversions towards equity. Maturity date or interest accruals are additional features incorporated in convertible notes.
- Legal Documentation: SAFE Notes are known for being simple contracts, generally just agreements between investors and startups, while convertible Notes require more detailed legal documentation, including Promissory Notes setting forth terms and conditions of such loans made by them.
- Market Prevalence: Recently, SAFE notes have gained a lot of popularity, particularly in Silicon Valley, and are frequently used by new start-ups. Convertible notes have been one of the more established and widely used investment instruments in startup finance with a longer history of use.
It should be pointed out, however, that the specific terms of SAFE notes may differ from one note to another (based on individual negotiation and agreement). Startups and investors should acquaint themselves with the terms of these securities, including conversion mechanics as well as investor protections, to enable them to make informed decisions regarding their investments.
Factors When to Use SAFE Note vs. Convertible Note
In choosing between a SAFE note or convertible note, it will be necessary for the investor’s choice and the start-up’s needs. Each tool has its particular strengths and caveats. Below are some factors to consider when deciding whether to issue either type of convertible security:
- Consider Simplicity. If you want things simple, then SAFE notes will always win over convertible Notes simply because they are less cumbersome hence requiring fewer negotiations. With this in mind, SAFE notes are best suited for people who need quick results.
- Evaluate Valuation. Additionally, SAFE notes also mean postponing valuation negotiations, when accurate valuations based on market conditions and company performance can be determined during future financing rounds. Conversely, convertible bonds come pre-determinedly equipped with valuation caps/ conversion prices that give certainty at the front end.
- Think about Investor Protection. SAFE notes usually have a discount rate or valuation cap, while in some instances there might be other significant features such as maturity dates/interest accruals along with convertible bonds. Consider what safeguards speak most to your risk appetites.
- Focus on Market Acceptance. In certain startup ecosystems like Silicon Valley, where SAFE notes have been getting traction coupled with widespread use of convertible bonds across various start-up financing markets
- Understand Investor Preference. Based on their familiarity, investment strategy or risk profile, some investors will prefer one instrument over the other. It is important to know what individual investors’ preferences are and which tool fits well with their investment goals.
Ultimately it depends on what that specific start-up and investor want. There is no definite answer as to whether any one of these instruments is better than the others. Therefore, given that particular investment opportunity, it would be wise to consult legal and financial advisors to assess each instrument’s unique requirements, risks, and returns.
Key Terms for SAFE Note vs. Convertible Note
- Equity Conversion: This involves conversions that happen whenever either a SAFE note or convertible note is exchanged into the equity of an issuing company at some point in time, such as during a subsequent funding round.
- Valuation Cap: A predetermined cap used by SAFE notes for converting to equity so that investors can get favorable conversion prices.
- Conversion Price: The predetermined price per share in case of converting notes into equities refers to clarity concerning the conversion ratio.
- Investor Protections: Refers to the additional benefits/ safeguards for such conversion process provided by both SAFE notes and convertible bonds, such as discount rates/ maturity dates, respectively.
- Legal Documentation: Compared with the more comprehensive legal documentation required for convertible bonds, SAFE notes usually have less sophisticated contractual agreements and terms involving less paperwork.
Final Thoughts on SAFE Note vs. Convertible Note
Investors should consider simplicity, valuation, investor protection, market acceptance, and investor preferences when choosing between a SAFE note and a convertible note. One streamlined approach to this is through SAFE notes, which avoid discussions of valuation and have features that are friendlier to investors, such as caps on valuations and discounts. By contrast, convertible notes come with upfront certainty from predetermined valuations and sometimes may even offer additional safeguards, for example, by maturity dates. Both startups as well as investors must thus carefully weigh their unique needs and preferences consulting professionals where necessary while negotiating terms that best suit their objectives or risk tolerance levels. At the end of the day, however, knowing the difference between SAFE notes and convertible notes can empower all stakeholders involved in decision-making within the dynamic startup financing environment.
If you want free pricing proposals from vetted lawyers that are 60% less than typical law firms, Click here to get started. By comparing multiple proposals for free, you can save the time and stress of finding a quality lawyer for your business needs.
ContractsCounsel is not a law firm, and this post should not be considered and does not contain legal advice. To ensure the information and advice in this post are correct, sufficient, and appropriate for your situation, please consult a licensed attorney. Also, using or accessing ContractsCounsel's site does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and ContractsCounsel.
