Home Q&A Forum Surface only conveyance of land

Real Estate

Real Estate Purchase and Sale Agreement

Texas

Asked on Nov 11, 2026

Surface only conveyance of land

I have had an attorney review and he has confirmed that this is a surface only conveyance contract. What in this contract (if any) would make a buyer think otherwise

Answers from 1 Lawyer

Answer

Real Estate

Texas

Answered 15 minutes ago

Ricardo A.

ContractsCounsel verified

Business Lawyer
Licensed in District of Columbia, Texas
Free Consultation
View Ricardo A.
4.8 (18)
Member Since:
December 24, 2024

In Texas, silence favors the buyer. Minerals ride along with the land by default, and only a reservation or exception in the instrument keeps them with the seller (Cockrell v. Texas Gulf Sulphur Co., 299 S.W.2d 672, 675 (Tex. 1956)). Cockrell A seller relying on implication loses, because the Supreme Court demands clear reserving language (Sharp v. Fowler, 252 S.W.2d 153, 154 (Tex. 1952)). Sharp A buyer can therefore reasonably read anything short of an express reservation as including the minerals. What would give a buyer that reading: No express reservation. The contract calls the deal “surface only” in a heading or recital, but the operative clause conveys “the Land” or “fee simple title”. The attached long-form commercial PSA does this: its “Land” definition is silent on minerals and Section 4 requires fee simple title. A granting clause that names the minerals. The attached General/Special Warranty Deed, the Deed without Warranties, and the Exhibit D deed to the short-form PSA all convey appurtenances “at any depth,” including “any oil, gas, and other minerals lying under the Land.” If that boilerplate survives in the deed exhibit, it contradicts a surface-only contract. A blank or missing reservation. In the attached Farm and Ranch agreement, the reservation depends on Paragraph E (“Exclusions or Reservations”) and the unchecked boxes in the reservation exhibit. The .docx also lists that exhibit as “F” but labels it “G”. On TREC paper, the Farm and Ranch Contract (25-17, ¶ 2F) routes every mineral, water, or timber reservation through an attached addendum. TREC 25-17 TREC’s mineral addendum (No. 44-3, ¶ B) treats conveyance as the default, with a reservation only where a box is checked. TREC 44-3 texas “Subject to” wording instead of “Seller reserves.” A clause making the sale subject to mineral reservations of record, or listing minerals as a Permitted Exception, limits the warranty; it does not retain anything for the seller (Wenske v. Ealy, 521 S.W.3d 791 (Tex. 2017)). In Ross v. Flower, the Austin court refused to treat “accepted subject to” wording as keeping the sellers’ minerals. Ross v. Flower farmprogress A reservation narrower than the seller assumes. Examples: “oil and gas” without “other minerals” (Moser v. U.S. Steel Corp., 676 S.W.2d 99 (Tex. 1984)), a royalty instead of the mineral estate, a fraction “of Grantor’s interest,” or silence on executive rights and surface access. “Surface only” left undefined. The surface estate is more than topsoil. Pore space stays with the surface owner absent contrary agreement (Myers-Woodward, Tex. 2025). Myers-Woodward Groundwater also stays with the surface unless severed, while produced water follows the mineral lessee (Cactus Water Services v. COG Operating, Tex. 2025). Cactus Water A buyer will expect water, sand, gravel, caliche, wind, and solar rights. Inconsistent deal documents. Examples: an LOI stating “Seller will convey all rights to all oil, gas, and minerals that it owns” (the attached Farm and Ranch LOI says exactly this), a listing saying minerals convey, an assignment of mineral leases, or royalty prorations at closing. An entire-agreement clause limits their contractual effect, but they support fraud, mistake, and DTPA claims. In Alvarado v. Bolton, 749 S.W.2d 47 (Tex. 1988), the buyers kept their DTPA claim on a mineral discrepancy despite merger. The deed itself. The contract merges into the deed at closing. If the deed omits the reservation, the buyer holds the minerals of record, and the seller’s remedy is reformation, subject to a four-year limitations period running from the deed (Cosgrove v. Cade, 468 S.W.3d 32 (Tex. 2015)). An unqualified warranty. A general warranty without excepting outstanding mineral interests invites a Duhig claim (144 S.W.2d 878 (Tex. 1940)). The title commitment. The standard mineral exclusion from coverage is not a reservation. Important to know that the title company has no obligation to determine mineral ownership.

Use of the ContractsCounsel Q&A Forum does not create an attorney-client relationship between User and any Lawyer User. The Forum is not a substitute for legal advice from a lawyer but is intended to be educational and to help the user determine if legal services are necessary. The Forum, Content, and communications on the Forum do not constitute legal advice.
Meet some lawyers on our platform

Jason G.

2 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Dolan W.

1955 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Sara S.

265 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

Amy B.

16 projects on CC
CC verified
View Profile

People Also Asked

Real Estate

Purchase and Sale Agreement

Texas

Asked on May 12, 2021

Are title company's law firms?

Going through real estate transaction and trying to understand.

View George O.
4.9 (5)

George O.

Answered May 12, 2021

No, but they can be fee offices, which means the law firm has entered into a contract with a title company to handle closings on behalf of the title company.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Real Estate

Purchase and Sale Agreement

Texas

Asked on May 12, 2021

Does Texas have any specific real estate rules?

I am moving from California and wanted to see if there is anything I should know.

View George O.
4.9 (5)

George O.

Answered May 12, 2021

Like any state, Texas does have rules specific to transactions occurring within its state lines. For example, the Texas Property Code governs most real estate matters, along with Landlord/Tenant matters. However realtors and transactions of that nature are governed by the Texas Occupations Code, which seems odd, but that is how it is.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Real Estate

Commercial Lease

Texas

Asked on May 12, 2021

What is a triple net lease?

I want to understand these better.

View George O.
4.9 (5)

George O.

Answered May 12, 2021

A triple net lease designates the tenant (lessee) as having the sole responsibility for any and all costs associated to the asset being leased in the agreement, with those costs being the net real estate taxes on the leased asset, net building insurance, and net common area maintenance. The lease received its name from the three “net” fees and may also be called a Net-Net-Net Lease.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Real Estate

Commercial Lease

Texas

Asked on May 12, 2021

Should I use a lawyer for commercial lease?

It is a very long lease and I'm not sure what it says. I also don't want to pay a fortune to have it reviewed to eat into my budget.

View George O.
4.9 (5)

George O.

Answered May 12, 2021

Yes! Before signing any contract/agreement/lease, or anything that appears to be a binding agreement, it is worth the money to have a lawyer review it. I charge a flat fee to review any and all agreements, so my clients know up front what they are paying, and they consider it a cost of doing business. The alternative, i.e. not having a lawyer review your agreements prior to signing, can be, and usually is, exponentially more expensive should a conflict arise (and they often do).

Read 1 attorney answer>

Real Estate

Warranty Deed

Texas

Asked on Jul 27, 2021

Texas deed and trust lawyer

Need warranty deed

View George O.
4.9 (5)

George O.

Answered Aug 23, 2021

Good morning - I do these daily and can walk you through the process.

Read 1 attorney answer>

Find lawyers and attorneys by city