Breach of fiduciary duty happens when an individual fails to meet their obligations and assigned duties and acts in a way that infringes on the fiduciary party. Moreover, a fiduciary duty is a responsibility of commitment and utmost care owed by the fiduciary to another individual, commonly known as the beneficiary or the principal. This blog post will discuss what is a breach of fiduciary duty and other relevant details, including its implications and legal remedies.
Implications of Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Fiduciary duty entails a legal and ethical responsibility that arises in various professional relationships, such as between a trustee and beneficiary, a company director and shareholders, or an attorney and client. The fiduciary must prioritize the other party's best interests while demonstrating utmost care, loyalty, and good faith. Nonetheless, breaching this duty can have far-reaching implications. Below are the consequences the fiduciary and the affected parties face in the event of a breach.
Legal Consequences
- Civil Liability: Violating fiduciary duty may lead to civil lawsuits filed by the affected party seeking compensation for the resulting damages. The fiduciary can be held personally accountable for any financial losses incurred due to their breach.
- Legal Remedies: The affected individual can pursue legal remedies, such as seeking injunctions to prevent further harm, rescission of agreements, or specific performance to enforce fiduciary obligations.
- Punitive Damages: In severe breaches involving intentional misconduct or fraud, courts may award punitive damages as a deterrent and punish the wrongdoer.
Financial Implications
- Restitution: Fiduciaries who breach their duty may be obligated to restore any unlawful gains or profits obtained through the breach. It may entail returning misappropriated funds or compensating for any financial losses suffered.
- Damage to Reputation: A breach of fiduciary duty usually damages the principal’s reputation, possibly resulting in a loss of trust from customers, associates, or stakeholders. Such harm to reputation can have broad repercussions, including missed business prospects and adverse impacts on professional standing.
Regulatory Actions
- Regulatory Investigations: Breaching fiduciary duty can trigger investigations by regulatory authorities such as professional associations, securities commissions, or government agencies. These evaluations might lead to punitive actions, fines, or even the cancellation of ownership, depending on the extent of the violation.
- Professional Sanctions: Professionals guilty of breaching a fiduciary duty may face sanctions within their respective associations or governing bodies, including suspension or permanent expulsion.
Personal Liability
- Indemnification: In certain cases, fiduciaries may possess personal liability insurance or be repaid by the organization they represent. However, insurance coverage may be limited or not apply if the breach was intentional or involved criminal conduct.
- Personal Financial Consequences: Fiduciaries who breach their duty may be personally responsible for covering legal expenses, fines, or damages awarded against them.
Reputational Damage
- Lack of Trust: Breaching fiduciary duty destroys trust between the fiduciary, affected parties, and the wider community. Rebuilding trust can be lengthy and challenging, impacting future professional opportunities and relationships.
- Impact on Future Employment: Individuals with a history of breaching a fiduciary duty may encounter difficulties securing future employment or professional positions, as potential employers prioritize candidates with untarnished records and strong ethical reputations.
Legal Recourse for Breach of Fiduciary Duty
A breach of fiduciary duty happens when an individual in a fiduciary position fails to meet their duties or engages in actions that are not in the best interests of those they are accountable for, such as beneficiaries or customers. Breaches can take various forms, including self-interested transactions, misuse of assets, failure to disclose conflicts of interest, negligence, or deliberate wrongdoing. Such infringements can result in monetary losses, harm to reputation, and lack of trust. Here are some common remedies available for breach of fiduciary duty.
Initiating Legal Action
The most prevalent legal remedy for addressing a breach of fiduciary duty is to file a claim seeking appropriate compensation and performance of specific action. To succeed in such a claim, the plaintiff must prove the following aspects:
- Presence of a Fiduciary Association: The complainant must prove that there was a fiduciary association between the involved parties.
- Breach of Fiduciary Duty: The complainant must establish that the defendant infringed their obligations through negligence, deception, or misconduct.
- Causation: The plaintiff must show that the breach of fiduciary duty directly caused harm or damage.
- Damages: The plaintiff must quantify and provide evidence of the losses suffered due to the breach.
Equitable Remedies
Apart from pursuing monetary damages, the plaintiff may seek equitable remedies to restore them to their position if the breach had not occurred. Equitable remedies can include:
- Injunction: A court may issue an injunction to prevent further harm or require the fiduciary to take specific actions.
- Rescission: In fraud or material misrepresentation cases, a court may invalidate the transaction and return the parties to their pre-contractual positions.
- Accounting: A court may demand an inquiry into the fiduciary's actions and need a detailed record of financial dealings to be provided.
Constructive Trust
When the fiduciary has gained an unfair advantage through their breach, a court may impose a constructive trust. This legal remedy compels the fiduciary to hold any illegitimate gains in trust for the benefit of the affected party.
Professional Disciplinary Actions
The affected individual may also report the infringement to the appropriate professional regulatory committee if the fiduciary has professional authorization, such as an attorney or financial consultant. These representatives can investigate the claim and inflict disciplinary actions, such as discontinuing or revoking the fiduciary's license.
463 projects on CC
Key Terms for Breach of Fiduciary Duty
- Fiduciary Duty: The legal obligation that mandates an individual to prioritize the well-being of another person, referred to as the heir or principal. This duty comprises commitments, including attentiveness, faithfulness, clarity, and avoiding conflicting interests.
- Violation of Fiduciary Duty: It refers to the breach or non-fulfillment of the fiduciary commitments promised to another individual. It arises when a fiduciary acts contrary to the beneficiary’s best interests or engages in activities prohibited by law or the terms of the fiduciary association.
- Duty of Loyalty: It is a duty that necessitates acting exclusively in the beneficiary's best interests and refraining from any interest conflicts. The duty of loyalty prohibits engaging in self-serving actions, competing with the beneficiary, or exploiting confidential information for personal gain.
- Duty of Care: It is a duty that demands exercising a reasonable level of skill, diligence, and prudence while carrying out responsibilities. Fiduciaries must make informed decisions and act, considering the beneficiary's best interests.
- Conflict of Interest: A situation where a fiduciary holds economic, personal, or other interests that could damage their capability to act impartially in the beneficiary's best interests. Fiduciaries must reveal any conflicts of interest and take suitable measures to prevent or address them.
Final Thoughts on Breach of Fiduciary Duty
In a nutshell, a breach of fiduciary duty happens when an individual authorized fails to meet their obligation and does something that causes monetary or personal harm to another party. This breach undermines the essential principles of loyalty, trust, and honesty that form the basis of fiduciary associations. Whether it involves financial consultants, corporate managers, trustees, or other fiduciaries, such breaches can have substantial legal, financial, and reputational repercussions.
If you want free pricing proposals from vetted lawyers that are 60% less than typical law firms, click here to get started. By comparing multiple proposals for free, you can save the time and stress of finding a quality lawyer for your business needs.
